Tips categories
Articles with tips for going green to help protect the environment we all affect!
 
bookmark or share this page
Green News Blog
Environmental stories, opinion pieces and site news
 
Renewable energy - solar power, wind and hot water
 
Special offer
20% off green cleaning products!  Wowgreen's range is  environment, family and pet safe!
::
Buy castile soap and save - special offer for GLT readers! Learn more about the many uses for castile soap
Article Options

bookmark or share this page
Popular Articles
  1. Brown rice vs white rice
  2. Hydrogen peroxide tips
  3. Castile soap
  4. Handy borax tips
  5. 30 baking soda tips
  6. White sugar vs raw sugar
  7. White bread vs brown bread
  8. Recycling styrofoam
  9. 24 handy lemon tips
  10. Uses for eucalyptus oil
No popular articles found.
Get involved!
Feel free to add comments to tips and blog posts & build on the information or click here to submit new earth friendly tips and environmental news items!
 »  Home  »  food  »  White bread vs brown bread
White bread vs brown bread
By Green Living Tips | Published  11/28/2006 | food , family
Switching from white to brown bread

I'll admit it, I was a white bread freak, it took many years for me to switch from white to brown/wholemeal; even though I knew that the latter was better for me and the production of brown bread was more earth-friendly.

The difference in taste between white and brown bread is significant, as is the texture and obviously the way it looks. When you are brought up on white bread, it can be really difficult to make the change. The way it was successfully introduced to me recently after many failed attempts was through "quasi" brown breads such as light rye. The taste difference was more subtle, which made for the perfect stepping stone to true wholemeal. These days I actually prefer brown bread to white. Try this strategy on your recalcitrant family member :).

There's some other things you might like to point out about white vs. brown as sometimes the words "because it's better for you" just don't cut it with a white bread addict:

White bread is made is from wheat flour from which the bran and germ have been removed. This is where much of the nutritional bread value is. White bread is lower in zinc, fiber, thiamin, niacin, trace elements and "good" fats and oils. White bread in many countries has to be fortified with vitamins and minerals *by law* during the bread making process. These are usually sprayed into the mix. It's somewhat ironic that the nutrients that are removed from wheat are re-added by this means. Nature provides, we destroy, then add it back in via a man made form.

Once the bran and germ is removed, the flour is bleached using potassium bromate, benzoyl peroxide  or chlorine dioxide gas. Potassium bromate is also known as Bromic Acid or Potassium Salt. It's an oxidizing agent, can be fatal if swallowed, is harmful if inhaled or absorbed through the skin and may also cause kidney damage. Benzoyl peroxide is another irritant that can kill animals, birds, or fish, and cause death or low growth rate in plants. Chlorine Dioxide is also a pesticide and even though it breaks down very quickly, it is ranked in the USA as one of the compounds most hazardous to the environment.

So even before the baker adds his chemical magic, there's some pretty solid cons relating to white bread. Another point to note is that anything that needs "refining" requires more energy resources to do so.

By the way, just because bread is brown in color doesn't necessarily mean it's brown bread in the traditional sense of the term, i.e. meaning whole wheat or wholemeal. Check out the ingredients on the bread that you buy and ensure that the first ingredient is whole wheat or wholemeal flour rather than enriched wheat flour or just wheat flour. Enriched/wheat flour is the same type of flour used in white bread. The presence of caramel also is an indicator that it's not true brown/wholemeal bread as caramel is used as a coloring agent. A couple of other ingredients to avoid if possible are fructose corn syrup and partially hydrogenated oil/fats; aka trans fats.

The general rule of thumb is the less ingredients in the bread and the presence of wholemeal flour as the major ingredient, the better it is for you - and the planet.

Have some more info to share about the nutritional or environmental pluses of brown bread? Please add them below.


 
bookmark or share this page
 
Michael Bloch
Green Living Tips.com
Article reproduction guidelines
 

 
Comments
  • Comment #1 (Posted by karley)

    can you please tell me if brown bread mould faster than white bread? website is great.
     
  • Comment #2 (Posted by Michael Bloch)

    Hey Karley, thanks for your kind feedback. That's a good question. It really depends on what's in the bread. Mass produced bread will generally keep better than home made bread because of the sugar, fat and preservatives. Also, environmental factors come into play such as humidity and storage, but generally speaking I've found that brown bread doesn't go mouldy as quickly as white - store or home made.
     
  • Comment #3 (Posted by Erik)

    My daughter had the following homework question that perhaps you can answer: Why does whole wheat bread toast faster than white bread? My initial thought was that it doesn't really toast faster but starts out brown already but then I thought that maybe it may have something to do with composition or moisture content. Do you have any insight into this question? Thanks!
     
  • Comment #4 (Posted by Michael)

    Hi Erik - your daughter's question is a good one :). This is somewhat of a guess, but I believe the reason that whole toasts faster than white is due to fat content usually being a little higher in whole wheat bread. If I'm wrong and you discover the definitive answer, I'd love for you to drop back and let me know! :)
     
  • Comment #5 (Posted by David)

    I have always favored sourdough bread due to its taste (some don't like it) but now I have discovered that an additional benefit is the probiotic factor. Also, I have not been able to locate 100% whole wheat sourdough. Another item of curiosity, "substantial" breads take a lot longer to toast than cheap white bread - the kind that you can wad up and make doughballs out of.
     
  • Comment #6 (Posted by Michael (Green Living Tips))

    mmmm... sourdough bread ... haven't had it in years :
    )!
     
  • Comment #7 (Posted by Mark David)

    Interesting article thanks. The process for making brown bread seems much simpler than making white bread. Why then, does brown bread always cost more in the shops?
     
  • Comment #8 (Posted by Michael (Green Living Tips))

    Hi Mark - I don't notice a price difference here in the supermarket, except with the more "designer" type wholemeal breads, but I suspect that where there are differences, it's a demand issue. I very occasionally still buy wholemeal bread from the store as backup supplies, but I buy it a day after it's baked as it's discounted. What I have noticed is there always seems to be more marked down brown bread than there is white bread. So, demand coupled with wastage may contribute to the price differences you are seeing.
     
  • Comment #9 (Posted by ravi)

    hi, i just wanted to ask, hw much brown bread can one eat during the day, is it bad to eat alot, i tend to eat 6 slices a day i f i can , is that healthy
     
  • Comment #10 (Posted by Michael [Green Living Tips])

    Hi Ravi. The USDA recommends 3 ounces of whole grain bread a day; which I think works out to be around 3 slices. I can't see eating more being unhealthy for you; but it does depend on the other ingredients in the bread. Everything in moderation I guess; but that's coming from someone who eats about 8 slices of bread a day :).
     
  • Comment #11 (Posted by Hannah)

    Hi, this site has been great!! I'm doing a biology investigation at the moment for College on the difference between mould growth on white and brown bread. You have answered all my questions on here :) but I'm just wondering if you know anything about the types of mould growth growing and if some moulds may grow faster than others? Thanks, Hannah
     
  • Comment #12 (Posted by Bailey)

    I am doing my science fair on Which bread molds faster white or "brown" and I was wondering if you could tell me why white molds faster like because of the ingredients and which mold. (Nothing about store bought or homemade please!)
     
  • Comment #13 (Posted by arasi)

    is whole grain white bread good?
     
  • Comment #14 (Posted by melanie)

    answers to a few previous questions:

    "Why does cheap white bread toast faster than brown"

    Cheap white bread toasts faster because it has a higher sugar content - it's the sugar turning brown. I imagine that if anyone has noticed brown bread toasting faster it might be because it's one of the ones with caramel in it? That's a guess.

    "Is six slices of wholemeal a day too much"

    With the question of the amount of bread to eat that's healthy that depends on your energy expenditure. If you are a male of healthy weight who is reasonably active (approx 30min of moderate exercise a day) then six slices of wholemeal bread would be quite reasonable. If you are overweight then it is probably too much. As long as you are eating five serves of fruit and veg a day as well and adequate protein (and don't eat heaps of bread at the expense of eating enough fruit and veg) then you probably have a healthy diet. Are you eating 6 slices because you are hungry? If so you would probably be better off getting a low GI grainy bread which will keep you fuller for longer. See next answer for more details...

    "Is grainy white bread good for you"

    Both white and wholemeal bread are high GI - in a nutshell this means they don't give you long lasting energy and you get hungry quickly after eating them. It's the seeds in bread that make it low GI which is much better than high GI. Different seeds also have extra nutrients and proteins which are great. Wholemeal has other benefits which you've all read about in the article. The best option is grainy, wholemeal bread. But eating grainy, white bread is a good way ahead of just eating plain white bread.

    See the recipe I posted on the bread baking comments page for a grainy, low GI bread.

    Hope this helps - this is a great website by the way!
     
  • Comment #15 (Posted by Michael - Green Living Tips)

    Thanks for the great input Melanie. Folks, the article where Melanie has added her wonderful recipe is linked to below: "Home baked bread" (you'll see her recipe in the comments section of the article)
     
  • Comment #16 (Posted by Karthik)

    "White bread takes more time and energy to toast than the brown bread"
    Guys, I read an article somewhere which makes sense to me "White bread tends to reflect heat (remember childhood lessons??) and therefore takes more time to toast while brown/ wheat breads absorbs heat and hence toasts quicker than whites"..
     
  • Comment #17 (Posted by Lulu)

    Hi, I just did a science experiment for school. It involed white bread and one fruit (out of pear, banana, orange, kiwifruit & apple)each in a bag for 7 days to see how much mold grew. I just finished and NOTHING happened to the white bread and there were a few specks of mold on the fruit and breadcrumbs. Do you know why this has happened? Please reply if you know as soon as you can as the results are due very soon! Thanks =)
     
  • Comment #18 (Posted by Callie)

    Dear Michael, I am confused about unbleached bread flour. Is this the same as regular white flour? I make all my breads at home. My husband loves white flour and I'm trying to find a nice compromise of a bread that tastes good but is also good for you. Does unbleached bread flour provide the same nutritional value as whole wheat flour??
     
  • Comment #19 (Posted by Adriana)

    Which type of bread will provide the highest level of sustained energy?
     
  • Comment #20 (Posted by Michael - Green Living Tips)

    Adriana, I don't profess to be a nutritional expert, but I'm told that low GI bread which is usually wholegrain, wholemeal...usual types of low GI are good. Basically food as close to it's natural form as possible. GI stands for Glycemic Index - you can learn more about the term here:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glycemic_index

    Callie, unbleached flour hasn't undergone the chemical treatments of bleached flour, so in that respect it's better for you - but it's still missing some of the nutrients as the bran and germ have been removed.
     
  • Comment #21 (Posted by Cristina)

    This is a very educational site. Its great. Quick question: How does everyone feel about potatoe bread? I do not know if its healthy or earth friendly, but its a different color if that means anything.
     
  • Comment #22 (Posted by Shirien)

    Wow! great article. I have a question though.. Does eating bread- white or brown- make you fat. In that context, is Brown bread better than white? I really need to know cos i need to lose come wt and my dad wants me to give up bread entirely and i just can not do that!
     
  • Comment #23 (Posted by melanie)

    Shirien,

    Bread will not make you fat persay, it's all about how much you eat and how much you exercise when it comes down to it. However, if you are trying to lose weight it is important to eat low GI bread which means you should have one with grains in it. This will keep you full for longer and mean you are less likely to snack on unhealthy stuff.

    Some people go on low or no carb diets to lose weight which might be what your Dad is referring to. Unless done under supervision by a doctor/dietician these are usually not sustained weight losses. It sounds like you love bread so don't cut it out of diet altogether or you'll never sustain it. But if you eat a large amount of bread then you should probably cut down as it is quite an energy dense food.

    Good luck :-)
     
  • Comment #24 (Posted by Lexie)

    I just read the ingredients list on my "wholemeal flour" packet. It contains wheat flour, wheat bran and thiamine. This suggests to me that it isn't really wholemeal flour, but rather white flour that's had a few goodies previously separated and then added back in. Is this the case?
     
  • Comment #25 (Posted by Heidi)

    I have been making fresh ground whole wheat bread for years. I am a home school Mom and make bread a couple of times a week for a family of five. I buy my wheat in 50 lb bags as well as oatmeal. Incidentally if you would like the shelf life of your bread to last longer simply add a bowl of premade oatmeal to a batch making three-four loaves of bread. Oatmeal is a natural preservative.
    I would highly recommend making your own. Bread is pretty easy to make and delicious smelling and tasting. To be conscous of using to much energy when I have my oven on a do alot of different things at once - I make homemade granola to cook while my oven is preheating.
    Thanks for the hints you offer on your site.

     
Submit Comment (reviewed before publishing)