Tips categories
Articles with tips for going green to help protect the environment we all affect!
 
bookmark or share this page
Green News Blog
Environmental stories, opinion pieces and site news
 
Renewable energy - solar power, wind and hot water
 
Special offer
20% off green cleaning products!  Wowgreen's range is  environment, family and pet safe!
::
Buy castile soap and save - special offer for GLT readers! Learn more about the many uses for castile soap
Article Options

bookmark or share this page
Popular Articles
  1. Brown rice vs white rice
  2. Hydrogen peroxide tips
  3. Castile soap
  4. Handy borax tips
  5. 30 baking soda tips
  6. White sugar vs raw sugar
  7. White bread vs brown bread
  8. Recycling styrofoam
  9. 24 handy lemon tips
  10. Uses for eucalyptus oil
No popular articles found.
Get involved!
Feel free to add comments to tips and blog posts & build on the information or click here to submit new earth friendly tips and environmental news items!
 »  Home  »  food  »  Mock meat recommendations
Mock meat recommendations
By Green Living Tips | Published  12/17/2008 | food
What's your favorite mock meat?
Ah, the dilemma of being an omnivore that cares about the environment. I received this email the other day:

Katie asks: "I'm trying to cut down meat consumption due to the effect livestock production has on the environment.. the problem is, some of the meat substitutes really taste bad. Do you have any recommendations?"
 
Katie, I know just how you feel. I'm still tussling with cutting meat consumption after starting to understand the environmental impact (not to mention the humanitarian issues). For meat eaters, it can be really hard to make changes, particularly if your first tests of meat substitution products aren't successful.
 
I have a few meat substitute products I've found quite palatable, but I'm sure Green Living Tips readers know of a lot more.

Let's turn this issue over to them as well!

Maybe we can help a lot of people out here instead of them forking out the cash for this stuff and hoping for the best.
 
So everyone, do you have a favorite mock meat or meat substitute you can recommend? Please  add your suggestions below .Be sure to state which country you're in as various products won't be available everywhere.

Michael's Mock Meat Picks

Here's my recommendations to help satisfy meat cravings (and  the companies aren't paying me to say this, nor are they aware I'm writing about them).

Sanitarium (in Australia) puts out some quite tasty products - and some that aren't; of course that's my personal taste.

The products I really like are Not Burgers and Tender Crumbed Schnitzels. They are very quick and easy and the Not Burgers come up great on the barbecue. We've tried these out on a few diehard meat eaters and they all enjoyed them.

The major ingredient is TVP - which stands for textured vegetable protein. TVP is defatted soy flour, a by-product of soybean oil production. It is high in protein and low in fat.

These products are heavily processed and have their share of preservatives and colors, but I'm just focusing on the lesser of the two "evils" environmentally speaking - just about satisfying that craving for meat. I'm sure the cows, pigs, chickens and sheep would prefer I did too :).

Sanitarium also make Not Bacon, which is ok taste-wise, but the texture can be a little like cardboard when you fry it - it should be fried very lightly. It is particularly good in potato salad!

Sanitarium also have a range of soy based sausages which to me are reminiscent of sawdust, but the rest of the family seems to like them.

In terms of canned stuff, Sanitarium's Casserole Mince is pretty good in lasagnes, tacos and other recipes in place of ground beef.

One other brand I recommend is Fry's. I've only tried their burgers so far, but they are wonderful. I mean really, really good; to the point that I have have no need to go back to meat based burgers.  I never thought I'd come across something that isn't just a compromise, but an equal in terms of taste. My only gripe with Fry's is that they are made in South Africa (really piles on the food miles) and that each burger is individually wrapped in plastic, which I'm assuming is because of the shipping issue. I'd really like to see the company start up a facility locally.

Fry's also recently cut the fat and salt in their products by 60% - I didn't start buying their burgers until after the change, but I don't find the burgers bland at all.

Update: Michael Jeffrey kindly offered the following recipe for mock meat patties.

"Although patties like Not Burgers by Sanitarium are delicious, you can also make wonderful patties at home- very inexpensively and simply.   There are just three things to remember.  Something bulky.  Something protein.  And something to bind it together.  For example:

Something bulky:  You can use left-over well-cooked rice --- or mashed potato -- or cooked Silver Beet/Spinach -- or mashed vegies from the night before --- or small pieces of wholemeal bread (crumbed in a blender) --- or grated carrot  -- or mashed pumpkin.

Add Something protein: e. g.  2 tablsp. of Millet Meal (fine) -- or Brown Rice Flour -- or Almond Meal -- or Sunflower Meal --- or L.S.A.  (Linseed, Sunflower and Almond meal)  -- or Ricotta Cheese -or Grated hard Cheese -- or mashed Tofu (best done in a food processor).

Something to bind it:  Two beaten eggs -- or Egg-Like Powder with water -- or melted cornflour and gravy powder --  or Spinach Dip.  The mixture has to be thick. 

Add herbs and a little salt and pepper to taste. Form into patties with the hands.  Place in fry pan.  Sprinkle with Sesame Seeds or other seeds (delicious!)  Fry on both sides until set.  You can make a lot of patties for a coming party, or enough for two dinners and lunch.  Keep them in the freezer or fridge."

So, over to you folks - please make your mock meat recommendations below, and don't forget to include your country so we don't send others looking for items that likely won't be available to them!


 
bookmark or share this page
 
Michael Bloch
Green Living Tips.com
Article reproduction guidelines
 

 
Comments
  • Comment #1 (Posted by Angie)

    MorningStar has a great line of meat substitutes!! Their "Crumblers" are absolutely delicious and you can sub them for anything that calls for ground beef. They have a great seasoned taste, only need to heat up, and have more protein than meat.
     
  • Comment #2 (Posted by Meagan E)

    Okay, this is going to be a long answer...

    First off, it's AWESOME that everyone wants to cut their meat consumption and I definitely want to help. I've been a pescetarian for 8 or so years now, so I've tried a lot of veggie meats.

    I live in the US, so I'll be dealing with the brands we have here.

    The key thing to know is that you need to buy different brands based on what type of what type of meat you're emulating in the recipe. There is no one brand that is good at everything.

    *For unbreaded chicken - DEFINITELY Quorn brand. Wow, is it awesome. You can buy "naked chick'n filets" or in chunks. It's soy free and made of mycoprotein, but uses egg white, so it's not vegan. And it is my favorite chicken substitute. Now, the caveat... Reportedly mycoprotein makes some people sick. But the lawsuit started on this basis was backed by rival veggie-meat makers Gardenburger, which sounds awfully suspicious to me. And I have never had a problem with it.

    http://www.quorn.us/

    * For breaded chicken - Morningstar farms Chik'n Patties

    You can get nuggets & patties, plain or with various spices. Awesome for a mock chicken wrap or sandwich.

    http://www.seeveggiesdifferently.com/

    * For beef - Boca Burger

    You can get patties or crumbles. Great for nachos.

    http://www.bocaburger.com/

    * For sausage - Morningstar Farms Veggie Sausage
    For snacking at breakfast, the links are fine, but if you are cooking with this, DEFINITELY get the patties or the crumbles. This is hands down the best meat substitute out there, in my opinion. My boyfriend likes my veggie sausage gravy better than any regular sausage gravy he's tried since.

    * For deli Ham - Worthington Veggie "Ham"

    I used to be able to get this at my local Kroger when I lived in Michigan, but they stopped carrying it, and I haven't seen it since. I don't know if it's still around but it was awesome.

    * For Hot Dogs - Morningstar Farms Veggie Dogs.

    * For bratwurst / sausage dogs - Boca Italian Sausage

    Great on the grill.

    * For Deli Turkey or Turkey Roast - Tofurkey

    Oh so good! Great on Thanksgiving.

    * For other deli meats - You're out of luck.

    Seriously. I have tried Yves Veggie deli meats, and... they aren't very good. I haven't found a brand I really like.

    Now, some other points....

    In veggie restaurants, seitan (a substance made from wheat gluten) is sometimes used. I haven't worked with it much myself, but I have eaten it in restaurants as everything from mock roast beef to mock chicken "wings" and it is FABULOUS. Seems like it would require a little more work than the pre-packaged stuff mentioned above, but it seems worth it.

    I have never been able to work with tofu. I know some people can, but I've only ever successfully used it in a dessert. Sorry.

    In my opinion / experience, ability to cook and knowing your spices is HUGELY important in going vegetarian. You are probably going to be disappointed if you just try to eat veggie meats on their own (but as time goes by and you get used to them, you may do just that if you're in a hurry.) When switching, try and put them in recipes and play with spice blends and other ingredients. Try to recreate recipes from your favorite veggie restaurants (or convert regular recipes to veggie!)

    Lastly... If after a while you find, as a vegetarian or semi-veg, that you're gaining weight... Look into a raw or partially raw diet. Fresh veggies directly from the earth are a LOT better for you than soy products, which, I'm told can be mucus forming and not as beneficial to your health as the companies would have you believe. Not to scare you - it's taken me years and years to really get over meat and meat replacements and get to this point, so ease yourself in. Just something to think about.

    Hope this helps!
     
  • Comment #3 (Posted by Meagan E)

    PS - Morningstar Farms Bacon sub is okay - not that great on its own, but useful for soups, etc.
     
  • Comment #4 (Posted by Nix Smith)

    I agree that the Yves if You Please deli meats aren't very good, but their lasagnas and hotdogs are OUT OF THIS WORLD!

    I also second the votes for Morningstar crumbles and chik'n, as well as ALL Boca mock meat products. The Morningstar "bacon" is also really good (although it leaves an odd smell in your microwave)!
     
  • Comment #5 (Posted by Jennifer in Danbury, CT)

    I don't try to substitute a veggie alternative for meat, it can't be done. You have to have the frame of mind that you are eating something different or it will taste "bizarre!" I love a good portobello mushroom "burger" with roasted red peppers, sauteed onions and balsamic vinaigrette. I also like jalopeno poppers, broccoli and cheese nuggets, and I know I used to make use of boca burgers (a soy/veggie burger). Good luck finding your substitutes, dress them like vegetables, not beef and maybe you will have better luck with enjoying the flavours, ie ranch dressing and tomatoes on a veggie burger.
     
  • Comment #6 (Posted by Philip Stavenhagen)

    one of the best meat substitutes I know and make is wheat protein or gluten and is called in Japan SEITAN, it looks and tastes very much like meat and some of my friends did not know they were eating non meat!
     
  • Comment #7 (Posted by Ardith)

    As my husband has become a vegetarian for health reasons and I am on my way to being one by choice, we have come across some amazing soy meat substitutes for him (still looking for non-soy alternatives for me).

    Best Soy Meat Alternatives:
    - Gimme Lean breakfast "sausage"
    - Soyrizo "Chorizo" (unbelievably good)
    - Tofurky Peppered "turkey" lunch meat slices
    - Morningstar "bacon" (it's incredible)
    - Morningstar Grillers Prime "hamburger" patties
    - Morningstar "Chicken" Griller patties
    - Gardenburger BBQ Vegie Riblets

    All of these products offer great texture and taste. The Soyrizo and Gimme Lean sausage can be used for a number of different recipes.

    We highly recommend your readers check out these products for yourselves. We believe you will pretty amazed yourselves with how good they are.

     
  • Comment #8 (Posted by Scott - Vermont)

    I am a staunch meat eater, but when I need a break I head for the Morning Star Chix products...
     
  • Comment #9 (Posted by Ginger)

    I like Worthington Choplets cooked a la Parmigiana: breaded, browned in olive oil, topped with Newman's Own Sockarooni sauce, mozzarella and freshly grated Parmesan... they're chewy and meaty, and all of those other good flavors predominate. My favorite comfort entree!
     
  • Comment #10 (Posted by Monica)

    My first favorite veggie burger is the Sunshine Burger. They only use 4 ingrediants and it tastes wonderful! The second is the original vegan boca burger. I thought that I would hate it, but I surprisingly really liked it. Other than that... I just use tofu or tempeh.... I was never a big meat eater in general.
     
  • Comment #11 (Posted by Iris)

    Boca's original Ch'kn patties should be vegan. I used to buy vegan meat replacements until I read up on genetically modified foods (many/all contain soy or are made with GM ingredients). However, there are some brands (I forget the name of one I was trying to think about...) that base their substitute meats on organic soybeans or are all organic themselves. So, I thought that was pretty awesome.

    I do buy organic "extra firm" tofu (so that's not GM) as a meat replacement because I am a vegetarian. I eat it in moderation though -- like every other day or once or twice a week. So, that's always an option too.
     
  • Comment #12 (Posted by Sharon)

    I can see I am not the only person who thinks Morning Star products are absolutely GREAT. We have been eating them for years. The Black Bean Grillers, Sausage Links and Patties are always in our freezer. I defrost in the mircowave for 2 minutes, then place in a non-stick skillet sprayed with Pam & turn the heat up high. This gets the patties and grillers krispy on the outside; just the way we like them.
     
  • Comment #13 (Posted by Elaine)

    I have to agree with many of the previous posts that Morning Star has a great line. I use their Sausage Style and Griller Crumbles in any recipe that calls for ground beef. My husband, who is a big meat eater, will even eat it.
     
  • Comment #14 (Posted by Nikki)

    I'm from Indiana and I've tried A LOT of faux meat and my favorites are Tofurky Slices, Tofurky Roast, and Boca for their Burgers and "Chicken" Patties.

    And my husband makes our our Seitan, but there's a boxed type that's fabulous too for stir fries.

    Congrats and cutting down!
     
  • Comment #15 (Posted by Daniel)

    There are lots of great products out there. For the most part, I highly recommend everything by Boca, Morningstar, Quorn, Lightlife, and Yves. One note though - in my opinion these things do not cook well in the microwave. They taste MUCH better cooked in a skillet or a toaster oven. Some specific recommendations:

    Best ground beef - Yves (friends don't know its fake, especially in Mexican foods, Italian foods, etc.)
    Best ground sausage - Lightlife
    Best sausage links - Morningstar
    Best sausage patties - Boca
    Best burger - Boca (all varieties, but All-American is closest to the real thing)
    Best non-burger burger - Morningstar's Black Bean Burger
    Best chicken nuggets - Lightlife
    Best chicken patties - Lightlife
    Best unbreaded chicken - Quorn
    Best hot dogs - Morningstar
    Best sausages (e.g., Italian sausage) - Boca or Lightlife
    Best random substitute - Melissa's Soyrizo (fake chorizo)
     
  • Comment #16 (Posted by )

    GARDENBURGERS -Sundried tomato - they are the best that I have tried. They are made with whole grains and I can pronounce every ingredient!! No preservatives. USA.
     
  • Comment #17 (Posted by Small Footprints)

    Hi!

    For commercial meat substitutes, I really like the original, vegan, Boca Burger. For hot dogs, we go with the vegan Yves.

    We make our own seitan (there are all kinds of recipes on the Internet) and turn it into "chicken" fried steak. I also have a recipe for Salisbury Steak which uses Gimme Lean beef flavor and vegetarian burger crumbles ... it probably is the closest thing we've had to the original. I'd be happy to share the recipe ... just drop be a line or visit my blog and leave a comment with your email.

    Besides the burgers, dogs, and Salisbury steak, we've actually found that eating Portabello mushrooms or tofu is a more satisfying meat substitute. Sometimes trying to duplicate the exact taste and texture of meat is disappointing.

    Small Footprints
    http://reducefootprints.blogspot.com

     
  • Comment #18 (Posted by Jess)

    Hands down the best chicken/turkey taste and texture is a product called Quorn (actually made of mushrooms)
     
  • Comment #19 (Posted by jw)

    First I think that one should not consume too much mock meat. Soy Protein Isolate should be avoided (too hard to digest). Second, a lot of these products have a pretty high carbon footprint, so the less packaging the better. I buy local seitan in containers that can be recycled. Field Roast is clearly superior in their products, but they are a little pricy. 4 big sausages at Whole Foods is $5.99. They are totally worth it. It's not "mock meat" per se, but marinating a hunk of grainy tempeh in BBQ sauce and then grilling it can be very satisfying.
     
  • Comment #20 (Posted by christine bourke. Dubbo Australia)

    Mushrooms, preferably the big flat ones are a good meat substitute, they make a yummy stroganof.
     
  • Comment #21 (Posted by lyn)

    for people trying to cut back on meat for health /environmental reasons, it may be easier to use products such as TVP to "stretch" meat. My hubby cant stand fully vege food, but i get away with using about 1/4 meat and the rest ground beans or TVP in chilli, stroganoff, lasagne etc - they still taste "real".
     
  • Comment #22 (Posted by Jeanne - South Africa)

    Mock meat options for vegetarians and vegans are limited in South Africa - but local manufacturer Fry's make a great range of TVP products.
     
  • Comment #23 (Posted by Nicole - Ontario, Canada)

    One thing I've heard, and then noticed for myself, is that mock meats start tasting better based on how long it's been since you've eaten actual meat. So if you're still eating meat and looking to substitute, it's going to be harder than if you've been veggie for a year or more.
    That said, I generally prefer the mock meats that resemble food that's already way-processed, like chicken nuggets. I use Schneider's chick'n nuggets because that's all that is available where I live. (http://www.schneiders.ca/whatsNew.aspx?date=september2006&item=1)For beef-flavoured foods, I really like President's Choice vegetarian meatballs, and their burgers too (that make a really good portabello swiss). (http://www.presidentschoice.ca/FoodAndRecipes/GreatFood/PCSearchResult.aspx/keywords/meatless)
     
  • Comment #24 (Posted by Lisa)

    Linda McCartney sausages are the best bet for all meat eaters sampling the veggie/vegan cuisine. Loads of meat eaters i know actually like these a lot and don't just put up with them! (and they're vegan)

    www.lindamccartneyfoods.co.uk

    stocked in all supermarkets as well as the wholefood shops -easy to get
     
  • Comment #25 (Posted by Michael - Green Living Tisp)

    Thanks for all the suggestions so far folks!
     
  • Comment #26 (Posted by Lisa D.)

    I live in Sudbury, Ontario, Canada. While our choices here are more limited than in Southern Ontario, I highly recommend the following:

    Somebody mentioned earlier two President's Choice Products--the meatless meatballs and the meatless Portobello Swiss burger. I also agree that these are great but I find that they have a lot of fat in them, for ex. for 6 of the meatballs there is 14 grams of fat. If you are looking for something a little more health conscious, then you might want to try the Presiden't Choice Blue Menu line. Although they don't have meatballs, they do have the following meatless products which in my opinion are all great:
    -beef strips
    -chicken strips
    -soy burgers
    -hot dogs
    They may even have more products but these are the ones I am most familiar with. Unfortunately, here in northern Ontario, there is not an overwhelming demand for some of these products so their availability may be limited sometimes.

    Additionally, as someone mentioned above, Schneider's also has a number of meatless products:
    -chicken nuggets
    -chicken burgers
    -meatballs that are lower in fat than PC
    -chicken cordon bleu
    -broccoli and cheese stuffed chicken breast
    -they used to have chicken and beef strips but they were taken off the market up here, I don't know if they are still available in other areas.

    I personally, love the Yves Veggie Turkey and Veggie Roast Beef but am not fond of the other deli slices. Other good Yves products are the ground round original flavour and the chicken ground round.

    Hope this helps some Canadian readers.

    p.s. presidents choice products are available in the following stores that I know of:
    -Real Canadian Superstore
    -Your Independent Grocer
    -Loblaw's
    -Zehrs


     
  • Comment #27 (Posted by Amanda)

    I live in Tasmania, Australia and am having difficulty finding vegetarian food. I have found Sanitarium Vegie Delights and they are delicious. I had some TVP shipped from the USA as it doesn't seem to be available in Australia. Is there anyone who can offer suggestions for those of us Downunder?
     
  • Comment #28 (Posted by LizLovesVeg)

    I've been a pseudo-veg now for 1+ year, still eat seafood ( and animal products). For anyone trying to go veg for whatever reason(s)-and there are many- I think the transition is helped IMMENSELY by use of fake meat products. PLEASE keep in mind that there are alot of crappy fake meats out there but alot of good- so kudos to you for doing your research.

    I highly recommened:
    -Burgers: Morningstar Grillers Prime are crazzy good. Morningstar Tomato Basil Burgers are delish too. I am not too crazy about Boca's line.

    -Chicken: Boca Spicy Chicken patties are great, Morningstar's Buffalo Chx Wings good also.

    -Turkey: Quorn (spelling?) Roast tastes like turkey. It's on the dry side, but for $7 you have very decent mock turkey- good for dinner, slice it up for sandwiches. I cannot recommend ToFurkey, I thought it was disgusting and it ruined my Thanksgiving.

    -'dogs: this is hard. Morningstar makes a GREAT corn dog. I can't recommend anything else... the texture is just all wrong with alot of brands.

    -Steak strips, Ground meat, Chik strips- Morningstar wins. Although I don't think they have much competition. I'd try to sub veggies though for most recipes b/c it's a hit or miss with ppl.

    For vegans-

    -Cheeses- mostly gross. can't recommend anything.

    -Tofu scrambles mock scrambled eggs really really well.

    Miscellaneous-
    Morningstar Bacon--really good, be VERY careful not to overcook these suckers WILL burn fast if you dont watch them. Taste just like crispy bacon--okk not just like, but damn it hits the bacon spot without the guilt of murdering an animal with an IQ of a 3 year old human and more intelligent than a dog.

    Hope this is of help fellow vegs- just wanna say we rock guys-whatever our reasons may be- we are helping the planet and our children-hopefully more and more people see the light****
     
  • Comment #29 (Posted by )

    I'd just like to thank you bunch for providing some good info. I am a staunch meat eater who just happened to come by a package of boca chili. I confess, I did put some regular cheese on top of it. I was actually quite surprised at the result and really had a hard time telling it was not meat. I can't say I am a complete convert by any means...what I can say is if more products like what I ate are available, I will be eating much more of them.
     
  • Comment #30 (Posted by jan)

    Boca Chik'n patties (both regular and spicy) are really good. I eat a lot of faux meat products, but that's the one I eat the most. They're too darn good.

    One of my co-workers (he says meat comes from the Meat Tree) has become a chik'n patty eating convert, because they smelled so good whenever I had some heating up in the kitchen.

    (Microwave for one minute, then toast.)
     
Submit Comment (reviewed before publishing)