Tips categories
Articles with tips for going green to help protect the environment we all affect!
 
Renewable energy - solar power, wind and hot water
 
Special offer
20% off green cleaning products!  Wowgreen's range is  environment, family and pet safe!
::
Buy castile soap and save - special offer for GLT readers! Learn more about the many uses for castile soap
Article Options
This article has been added to your 'Favourites' list.
Popular Articles
  1. Brown rice vs white rice
  2. Hydrogen peroxide tips
  3. Handy borax tips
  4. Castile soap
  5. 30 baking soda tips
  6. White sugar vs raw sugar
  7. Recycling styrofoam
  8. White bread vs brown bread
  9. Uses for eucalyptus oil
  10. 24 handy lemon tips
No popular articles found.
Get involved!
Feel free to add comments to tips and blog posts & build on the information or click here to submit new earth friendly tips and environmental news items!
 
Green Living Tips on Twitter
 
Green Living Tips on Facebook

 
bookmark or share this page
 »  Home  »  home  »  Refillable vs disposable pens
Refillable vs disposable pens
By Green Living Tips | Published  10/19/2008 | home , business
Pens and the planet

I shudder to think of the number of disposable pens I've bought and consequently discarded over the years up until a decade ago when I was given a nice refillable stainless steel pen.

In the ten years I've had it, I've only had to buy a new replacement cartridge for the pen a couple of times - due mainly to my increasing use of a keyboard.

Even with my decreasing amount of writing with pen and paper, without the refillable pen I would have certainly gone through at least a hundred disposables by now - many of them would have wound up in the bottom of a drawer and dried out, or left in various places around the country.

Disposable pen consumption

Here's a startling bit of info - according to this article, in early September 2005 Bic sold its 100 billionth disposable ballpoint pen.

Just to put that figure into perspective, some quick calculations I ran:

- Each pen is approximately 5.5 inches long
- Multiplied by 100 billion = 8,680,555 miles
- The circumference of the earth at the equator is 24,900 miles
- 100 billion pens laid end to end would circle the earth 348 times

While Bic is the largest manufacturer of disposable pens, it's certainly not the only one, so the number of disposable pens floating around the planet must be truly astronomical - and by "floating" I mean it pretty much literally.

Another frightening figure I've seen bandied around the Internet regarding the number of disposable pens used each year in the USA is a staggering 106 billion.

Environmental considerations

Once a pen has finished its serviceable life, or lost - which is most often the case, it doesn't simply disappear into thin air, although it may seem that way the rate they seem to vanish when you need one.

These disposable pens ultimately wind up in landfills and in waterways. Being made of plastic, they don't break down quickly and plastics are also usually made from crude oil.

A good refillable pen can last a lifetime. However, they do use cartridges which need to be disposed of. The cartridges are metallic, so they can be recycled.

Disposable vs. refillable - comparing costs

An entry level refillable pen will cost you around $10 including the first cartridge. The refills cost around $5. A pack of 12 disposable pens are around $5.

The refills last a good deal longer than a single disposable pen and given the throw away mentality we have in connection with disposables, we tend not to take good care of them, increasing consumption. So, with care, I think you'll find the costs of buying refills to be comparable with disposable pens.

By the way, you can also get refillable whyteboard pens (aka white board - depending on which country you're from) these days.

Keeping track of your refillable pen.

I never lose things, but I do misplace a lot of stuff that I never find again :).

Pens are *really* easy to lose. I'm very surprised that I've managed to hang onto my refillable pen for so many years - throughout quite a few job changes and house moves.

I think the key is that this pen means something to me. It was given to me by my coaches who had the words "Go Michael!" engraved on it. It immediately became my "lucky" pen and subconsciously I've taken better care of it than previous writing instruments.

If you're going to buy a refillable pen, if you lose one every few months there will hardly be any environmental benefit and certainly no financial incentive. It sounds corny, but give your pen a name, assign a personality to it or have it engraved with something that has importance to you. By spending a few bucks on a good quality pen you'll be far more likely to hang on to it. Bond with your pen :)

Putting disposable pens to good use

There doesn't appear to be options to recycle disposable pens as yet - and I'm not even sure of the plastic resin code used for most pen bodies. I'd love to see pen manufacturers implement takeback programs.

Currently, the only option seems to be to reuse them to help keep these items out of landfill for a while. If you've got a ton of pens to get rid of, consider sending them to The Pen Guy who uses old pens for rather interesting art projects. Similarly, you could probably give the pen bodies to school crafts departments for the kids to use in their projects.

If you have any ideas for reusing disposable pens, please add them below!


 
bookmark or share this page
 
Michael Bloch
Green Living Tips.com
Article reproduction guidelines
 

 
Comments
  • Comment #1 (Posted by Nathaniel)

    Pencils, while less permanent, are obviously the "greener" choices. Standard wooden pencils do use wood and there is a lot of waste made from them. However, the waste and/or shavings can be used in composting. I don't think the small amounts of graphite and clay would cause any problems for your plants. A mechanical pencil is cheap, and easily refillable and you don't have to worry about the cartridges being recycled.

    Bic should try to invest research in technologies that would allow their pens to break down naturally. There are biodegradable plastics out there. All they really need is for the pen to last out perhaps three times it's average age (as far as usage) and then fully decompose in a somewhat moist environment (such as a landfill) in less than ten years. As long as they could keep such a pen cost effective, they could really make a difference with such a pen.
     
  • Comment #2 (Posted by The Pen Guy)

    Thank you so much for the mention, its nice to know that I have a very unique pen niche. I managed to cover my Mercedes Pens Art Car in over 10,000 pens in the past three years. I am also currently seeking to get a hold of 250,000 pens or more for my next big project. If you can help or know anything about going about this please lt me know. All the best:)
     
  • Comment #3 (Posted by Michael - Green Living Tips)

    Nathaniel, thanks for your contribution.

    Costas, thanks for dropping by - I'll make mention of your request in my next newsletter :)
     
  • Comment #4 (Posted by elizar (Philippines))

    Such a small tool, yet the numbers really add up.
    This article really enlightens me to be more conscious about the things I buy and think more of the environment.

    Thanks Michael!!!
     
  • Comment #5 (Posted by Sheila)

    It's truly ironic that I have been thinking about this issue too, as I surveyed my office for something to write with but found only dry disposable pens. It's truly puzzling that ANYTHING made of plastic can be placed on the market without a recycling code on it, and even more puzzling that disposable items are being made out of a substance that will last pretty much forever... have you heard anything about cosmetics packaging? That's another doozie just waiting for reinvention. I have searched the Internet to see if the United States has ANY ability to recycle cosmetics and ran into a resounding "NO". I know there are women who will never give up cosmetics, but it sure would be nice if cosmetic companies would worry less about the pretty little package (perceived obsolescence) and worry more about what their customers are absorbing through their skin. It sure would be nice if they could develop a more uniform refill system like Mary Kay uses in their packaging (not a plug, I don't sell it). This company sells a container that can hold three pallettes of eyeshadow- they are removable and interchangeable. It really would be a day to celebrate when the cosmetics companies could figure out how to make this happen, because I'm fairly certain that the amount of unrecyclable plastic generated by them far exceeds the disposable pen business.
    Thanks for the info about the Pen Guy. I will most certainly keep him in mind when my pen runs out.
     
  • Comment #6 (Posted by Beth, aka Fake Plastic Fish)

    Hi there. Refillable pens with cartridges are okay, but refillable pens with converters are BETTER!

    I use a Lamy fountain pen with a cartridge converter that allows me to refill it from a pot of ink on my desk. It's not hard. And there's zero plastic waste.

    I included it in a post back in August of last year:

    http://www.fakeplasticfish.com/2007/08/reducing-plastic-waste-in-workplace.html
    Before buying your next cartridge, see if there is a converter you can buy for your pen. You might like it.

    Beth

     
  • Comment #7 (Posted by frank)

    I've thought about the disposable pens in the landfill before and now I use pencil except when I have no choice (checks etc).
     
  • Comment #8 (Posted by Michelle)

    Actually, I've read that the cosmetics brand MAC takes back used lipstick containers. If you turn in 10 of them they give you a free lipstick! :D
     
  • Comment #9 (Posted by katrina schumann)

    thanks for the article. I went to Staples & spoke with them; some of the so called "disposables" actually have refills you can buy but then you still end up with the plastic. I was getting really frustrated but now I know I am going to get the converter or whatever from the previous person's post. I actually had thought of going back & using an "ink" pot; whoo hoo! now I can pass the information on to lots of others so we can all get on the band wagon! If consumers (enough of us) just say NO the companies will change. Again, if enough of us contributed $1 we could make our own & not have to worry about the other companies getting up to snuff! Re cosmetics: www.pioneerthinking.com has great tips for making your own cosmetics without using any chemicals etc, & a great "vaseline" type product using beeswax.
     
  • Comment #10 (Posted by Jenny)

    Currently the only thing I can think of to do with disposable pens is to use them for props in play(Perhaps an office scene?)
     
  • Comment #11 (Posted by Kim)

    Beth is correct. Sorry, but fountain pens are "alive and well" and a great alternative to the sticks. Are they good for forms in triplicate? No, but neither are triplicate forms doing us much good with three times the paper use.

    Seriously, filling a good pen from an ink bottle is a very realistic alternative. One bottle of ink will last longer than 2 or 3 boxes of sticks, and the bottled fountain pen inks come in hundreds of colors and formulas (don't use india ink in a fountain pen - it isn't the same as fountain pen ink). Also, for archival purposes, there are "bulletproof" inks which are guaranteed fraud and alter proof and are permanent on the paper for as long as the paper exists.

    Fountain pens come in so many styles and sizes, and even many of the vintage pens are still going strong 100 years later (I have 2 pens in use dating back to 1903). And yes, there are even repair guys out there, too.

    I could go into much more, including the benefits of less wrist pressure and arthritis relief, but then I'd be going into an even more extensive essay.

    So, perhaps consider the even greener alternative in the fountain pen.

     
  • Comment #12 (Posted by Mackenzie)

    Darn it, you're all reminding me that I need to go digging around and find my old calligraphy pens. I've got a few quills, some fountain (cartridge) pens, and one of those reusable plastic sticks that holds a nib...somewhere. After knocking a bottle of ink off my desk and staining my backpack, I switched back to pens-that-hold-their-ink. Fountain pens are much less mess than quills or other nib pens.
     
  • Comment #13 (Posted by B.)

    I was really enlightened by this article, usually I prefer buying disposables since I can come up with excuses to buy new ones. But now I'm thinking of purchasing a durable refillable pen.
     
  • Comment #14 (Posted by Jenni)

    I, sometimes, break the outside barrel, so I keep the inside part of the pen, with the ink, for the next pen.
    I use to get the free ones from doctors offices, but they have discontinued those, but still buy lunches and other stuff, to sway the doctors to pass on their products from pharmacies. I liked the fashion pens, and got refills for them, but now they are hard to find. I read on another crafty blog, that they use the barrels for crochet hooks, the small ones. That is a creative way to use for those hooks.
    I crochet, so I may do that, and share that idea with other friends who crochet too.
     
Submit Comment (reviewed before publishing)