Tips categories
Articles with tips for going green to help protect the environment we all affect!
 
Renewable energy - solar power, wind energy and hot water
 
Special offer
NEW - Green Deal Of The Day! Save 50 - 90% on earth friendly products!
::
Buy castile soap and save! Learn more about uses for eco friendly castile soap
Article Options
Popular Articles
  1. Brown rice vs white rice
  2. Hydrogen peroxide tips
  3. Uses for eucalyptus oil
  4. Handy borax tips
  5. Recycling styrofoam
  6. White sugar vs raw sugar
  7. Castile soap
  8. 30 baking soda tips
  9. White bread vs brown bread
  10. 24 handy lemon tips
No popular articles found.
Get involved!
Feel free to add comments to tips and blog posts & build on the information or click here to submit new earth friendly tips and environmental news items!
 
Green Living Tips on Twitter
 
Green Living Tips on Facebook

 
bookmark or share this page
 »  Home  »  water  »  Composting human waste
Composting human waste
By Green Living Tips | Published  06/10/2008 | water , home , health , garden , building
Poo.. it's good sh**

Poo is a crappy subject, but one worth covering; particularly because it allows me to use a lot of old puns - it's not often I get to giggle like a schoolkid when writing - I think the last piece where I did was my item "Kangaroos don't fart" :).

Poop fascinates me. When I'm out in the bush, you'll often find me poking around in animal poop to learn more about what they eat, how long ago they visited that spot and how they digest. It's a boy thing I'm told, but maybe it's just a Michael thing too.

Poo was part of my career at one stage - contract cleaning. I developed an odd relationship with it and cleaning up other people's sh** was a great leveler. The first lesson I learned is never brush a toilet with your mouth open. True story, one that I don't think I need to go into any more detail about - you can probably guess.

My preoccupation with animal poop aside, it's a serious topic. Poo is good.. sometimes. Chook poop, horse dung, cow patties; all sorts of poo makes for wonderful fertilizer. It's quite likely that some of the food you eat has been grown in amongst poop of some type.

Humanure

Human poo certainly doesn't have that good earthy vibe to it given our diets (unless you're a vegan) and what we usually do with it is a crime against the environment; even in countries with good sanitation. For example, we usually waste around 2 to 3 gallons of water flushing our blind mullets away. Let's see.. there's around 300 million people in the USA; multiply that by a conservative 2 gallons and times that by 365:

219,000,000,000 gallons of water used each year just to flush no.2's - add to that no.1's and the figure is astronomical!

Speaking of no. 2's, did you know that phosphorous which is used extensively in agriculture is in short supply around the world and that human urine is a rich source of it? We're flushing yellow, I mean gold, down our drains! Yes, your pee is precious!

My grandfather was a prisoner of war in World War Two and urine was used on prison gardens - it's likely without it, he would have been far more malnourished than he was when the war ended.

On top of all the water we waste, a great deal of energy and chemicals go into treating our waste once it hits the sewage plant; where they are in place. Additionally, over 2.6 billion people still do not have access to any form of improved sanitation that doesn't pollute water and soil.

As on the nose a topic it may seem to be, it's time we started tapping into these great resources which will also allow us to decrease our environmental impact.

Roughing it and pooping

Living rough at times out in the boonies, I've had to deal with this issue head on (hehe). I've used chemical toilets, but with low impact non-formaldehyde based substances.

While these toilets use as little as a cup of water for flushing; emptying and cleaning them is, well, put it this way, it looks nothing like the ocean blue fluid portrayed on the box that the toilet comes in. I have a strong stomach, but it's a job I used to dread; particularly after a week long trip. What you save on the flushing may also be made up in keeping the darned things clean.

I've tried the more natural way - a simple hole in the ground. It's quite liberating to be in the great outdoors and unshielded, but it turns out I have poo thieves on my patch - they were raiding at night and digging it up. Yech. One day, I'll figure out what type of animal would do such a thing, but I've found a way to thwart them - simply dig the hole deeper.

My waste then becomes fertilizer for the surrounding trees; i.e. humanure. But even this way isn't entirely efficient or earth friendly; as real composting requires the presence of oxygen - so I'll be altering this strategy further.

It also may be an ok approach if you have acreage without any neighbors close by, but I'm sure the local authorities would jump on you pretty quickly if you started digging holes in your back yard - and anyway, with a family of 4, you'd like soon run out of space to do so, not to mention a window box is probably totally unsuitable for apartment dwellers too.

We need to approach the dealing of human waste in suburbia in a more realistic way - such as the use of composting toilets.

Composting toilets and blackwater recycling

A composting toilet simply breaks down nasty, smelly poop into dirt - yep, soil, and nutrient rich soil at that. It basically works like most composting processes through the assistance of aerobic microbes that oxidize the carbon in waste to carbon dioxide, and the evaporation of water content through heat. The heat created in the process also helps to destroy pathogens and any disease.

What's left over after 3 - 6 months of composting is around 10% of the original volume and a product that can be safely spread on your garden. It really is amazing how much stuff breaks down when composted; in our family of four, which consists of a vegan and two veggie lovers (I'm the carnivore), we have never been able to fill our worm farm to capacity; all the veggie scraps basically break down to nothing - it's the same sort of principle with composting toilets.

Yet another option is a blackwater recycling system which processes everything that goes down the drain in your house; including the toilet. In places where a composting toilet isn't acceptable, a blackwater recycling system is the next best thing - we've had one and I can highly recommend them.

Composting toilets and blackwater systems are a little pricey, so there are other options which involve the use of a couple of buckets peat moss, sawdust, or even shredded junk mail to act as composting medium; perfectly hygienic, but again - your local authorities may feel otherwise.

Even if it is illegal in your town or state to create humanure without a fully approved composting toilet; I feel it's vital to know how to deal with your waste in case of disaster. One of the major killers after a disaster is disease; usually spread by faeces. What would you do in your household if the sewerage system suddenly stopped working in your area?

The Humanure Handbook

I'm certainly not an expert on the topic of humanure, but someone who knows far more than me is Joseph Jenkins; who published an incredibly informative and in-depth book called “The Humanure Handbook”. One of the wonderful things about this book is you can read its entire contents online free or download a PDF version (20 megabytes); which is also free.
 
I think Mr. Jenkins should have been right up there amongst candidates such as Al Gore for the last round of Nobel peace prizes for his contribution to raising awareness regarding human waste management.

Even if the thought of humanure makes you wrinkle your nose a bit, consider downloading and reading a copy of The Humanure Handbook as part of emergency planning. You never know when you may need that knowledge!

Ok, now I've got all that out of my system (giggles) I'll now return you to your usual GLT programming.

Do you have a composting toilet? Please share your experiences below. I mean general experiences of course, not detailed descriptions of incidents of use ;).




Michael Bloch
Green Living Tips.com
Article reproduction guidelines
 
Related Articles

 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Archived/older comments
  • Comment #1 (Posted by Jan)

    A little on the ick side Michael, but like you said it's a really important issue and as always you approach things in an entertaining and informative way! The Humanure Handbook looks like a great resource!
     
  • Comment #2 (Posted by naturalpapa)

    I've used a sawdust toilet (Humanure-style) for over 5 years, and it's easy, doesn't smell, and it generates tons of compost.
    http://naturalfather.blogspot.com
     
  • Comment #3 (Posted by Michael - Green Living Tips)

    Jan, thanks for the kind feedback. NaturalPapa; I'm going to give the sawdust approach a go soon when I'm out in the boonies, looks very effective. By the way, you have a great blog :)
     
  • Comment #4 (Posted by Michael - Green Living Tips)

    In somewhat of a coincidence, this item was posted up on ABC Australia's site an hour ago, entitled "Use poo, farmers urged"

    http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/06/11/2271675.
    htm?section=justin

    :)
     
  • Comment #5 (Posted by Pat in Colorado)

    As a Realtor in Colorado, this is a fascinating article. As you know, water is and has been an issue for years in this part of the country. In fact, I understand that water and the lack of it in the future will be the source of many tribulations. In fact, this year despite the conscious efforts of the population to conserve, the cost of it will be increased considerably by the provider. Just how would you suggest that compost toilet could be mass produced and distributed effectively in an area such as ours and how would you proposed to do it. I'm sure there will be many against it, but for those willing to try, it would be a great savings.
     
  • Comment #6 (Posted by Vivek Soley)

    You somehow missed an important use of human waste.

    Just as animal excreta, human excreta too can generate sufficient bio gas. I am told that one person's waste is sufficient for generating bio gas required for cooking food for that person. So in a way we can cook from our waste.

     
  • Comment #7 (Posted by Charl)

    Hi Michael

    Thought you might be interested in a waterless toilet developed here in South Africa - see www.gendarme.co.za.

    Regards
    Charl
     
  • Comment #8 (Posted by Christy)

    Many thanks for this great article and links. I am going to download the Humanure PFD immidiately.
    I have used compost toilets in Vorovoro, Fiji, where the Tribe wanted Eco-Cultural Experiment is evolving and now know how well they work.
    My companion and I are building a solar home where we live (currently on a sailboat) in Greece on the tiny island of Leros where water is precious. We will also use water from rain collection only supplimenting when absolutley necessary. It only rains between November and April, water is scarce in the summer. Two low flow toilets will be installed, but just out the back door will be our composting toilet which the both of us will use almost exclusively and save tons of water by doing so. The urine will be funneled off for use on the garden. Our "grey water" will go to watering the garden as well, running directly out from three "exits" in our plumbing system. I am excited to be building a eco friendly home after watching all of this develope over the last 30 years!
    I am orignally from Colorado/California.
    Again,many thanks,people need to know how flushing toilets waste SO much water and what the alternatives are.
    Christy
     
  • Comment #9 (Posted by Michael - Green Living Tips)

    Thanks for all your input everyone; good to see there's GLT readers who aren't squeamish about discussing the topic :)
     
  • Comment #10 (Posted by Kevin Harper)

    Your article was very interesting and thought-provoking, wish you could have left that fraud Al Gore out of it.
     
  • Comment #11 (Posted by ciccio)

    I was one of three boys and my father was an avid gardener.
    It is now more than 50 years ago, but at the time we were all embarrassed, our father would not let us use the toilet to urinate, we had to do it on his compost heap. Even more embarrassing, at the end of our little street was a pasture, after work he would put on his "gardening clothes" (to us rags) take his wheelbarrow and march down to the pasture followed by his three dogs, all to the derision of the entire neighbourhood. He would come back an hour so so later with a load of dung for his manure heap. I am older and wiser now, I mourn how prosperity has robbed us of our relationship with nature.
     
  • Comment #12 (Posted by TONY BENSON )

    Michael .First of all may I say what a great blog .It is one of the best I have ever seen.
    I have small charity in kenya www.h2ototo.org which you may just have a quick look at.Basically i have this thing about water. I agree with everything you say. I too think Jenkins deserves a nobel prize. The book is great even though I have not studied it in detail . I wrote and asked if they had a problem with me translating it into other languages . they didnt seem to mind at all. Anyway here goes .
    I believe that the biggest problem the world has is waste. Waste of water,food,plastics woods etc etc . . The only way that we will change that is to change our cultures to suit. I had a dream and still do ,to help a few people to improve their lives. I used to think that we could organise a G8 type summit, to change the world by giving everyone enough to eat including clean water ,just like Bob Geldof and his Feed the world money raising attempts .. This will not happen in our lifetime for numerous reasons. The biggest reason is the lack of willingness of the majority of people in the world to change the way they think . I will use humanure and water wastage as the examples . If you design a waterless toilet which is what i intend to do when i eventually settle with my wife in Africa,the problem you have is persuading others to use it properly . A man in the states had a u tube video which was good showing a compost heap where he took a container a distance away from the house to a boxed in compost heap using the jenkins humanure principles he placed the contents into the centre of the heap. the heap had plenty of air flow so it was aerobic . He covered the contents with vegetation hay ,straw or just grass and also included kitchen vegetnle waste(meat is not recommended ). he covered this heap overnight with wire netting to prevent birds or vermin. Great in principle. There was only very little water involved in washing the containers. This water was simply poured into the heap. I think this compost heap took a year to become suitable and I think that a probe thermometer showed a build up to 120 deg C . The barriers I see to this system and all others of a similar nature are as follows :
    The west meaning us in the UK ,The US and the less developed European countries all have been flushing away loads of water for well over 100 years. In London the invention of the wc saved a lot of lives in victorian england with an amazing network of sewers. Great but not sustainable. Huge investment by thames water and others goes into treating these billions of gallons daily in massive treatment works . Waste is not the word .It is a crime. How are we going to persuade a population of 60 million that flushing ******down a drain and polluting already treated water at great expense is not the way. We might get through to 10 % of the population but thats not enough . If you suddenly had a dry system of composting you would put thames water out of business overnight.Never going to happen is it. People are so used to just flushing away they dont really care. The only thing that makes them take some notice is when their water rates start rising. But it is like petrol prices when they rise people generally just accept it after whingeing for a while ( a pom thing mike).Politicians make token gestures by persuading people to buy toilets that use less water. this will only scaratch the surface of the problem,they need to make the use of water borne waste a criminal offence and come up with a universal safe clean completely waterless model . Not in my lifetime !!!
    Going back to the waterless toilet- What I want for my place in Africa and to help promote humanure is a design that can be incorporated adjacent to the house. What my wifes parents do in rural kenya is build a latrine using blocks of concrete and basicall y a large pit in the ground with a vent systems . This has disadvantages . by mixing urine with faeces it pongs badly and even 30 metres from the house can be unpleasant. Everytime you want to use the loo a walk down a path is needed. Predators dont stalk here but it is not ideal .
    What I have in mind is to build a bathroom with a toilet integrated but obviously the outlet being external . The whole house would be raised anyway and the outfall for waste would be a chute at say 45 or 60 degrees . The grass straw ,sawdust ideas could easily be used using levers similar to a water flush only with dry cover materials,without having to take a bucket every couple of days down the garden to the compost heap. Obviously the whole thing would be vented and easily accessible from outside the bathroom with trap doors to suit . Two toilets could be built side by side so that they could be dealt with on a rotation basis . a wheel barrow could easily be used to distribute the results onto the appropriate plot. I use free horse manure to kickstart my compost heap in the UK . It is pretty harmless gear and contains loads of worms which help breakdown all the kitchen compost . Kitchen compost could easily be added to my humanure toilet from a separate side shoot . I believe the same could happen with urine . People would need to be educated into urinating into separate container to prevent the pong . Dry faeces is nowhere near as pongy as that mixed with urine.
    Any small amount of water that may be used in this bathroom would come from an elevated tank either externally or in the roof space . a comprehensive rainwater collection system (tropics remember) would satisfy most our water needs( greywater ).Any blackwater would have to kept separartely from greywater.Greywater would be filtered several times(bespoke or sand methods) and fed into a reed beed or similar to feed trees plants and flowers.
    This all sounds great in theory and i will explain why I dont think either the developed world or the whole of the third world will adopt this thinking enough . The developing world especially Africa and India have cultural issues to overcome.It is taboo in many places to apply any system of putting treated material back into the soil . proper composting is alien in many cases .Forcing education on people smacks of imperialism .All you can do is sow a few seeds and try to spread the word.In China they have used what they call "night soil" for centuries and it is a valuable resource which people actually buy and sell. In the west we have a problem with taboos aswell.How to change old ways is hard .Also urban methods may have to be adopted which are a lot different from rural methods.I think whatever the system is it needs to be maintained . education is vital . Time and time again one sees well meaning coun

    Hope you like ideas with all your experience of the bush help me design my elevated domestic basic rural toilet. I could alittle sketch ,


     
  • Comment #13 (Posted by Edee)

    I just returned from a week long outdoor ceremony where a version of this method was used. Makeshift toilets were made of old 2x4's and a plastic bucket with sawdust was placed under the structure. Each time you used #2 you sprinkled sawdust on it which was in another bucket in the same area. We had several homemade toilets and they were emptied each day. They were taken to a compost pile about a quarter of a mile away. It had straw and screen to keep flies away. I was assisting on the waste management team so I got to do the "big one" one day. I found out why they asked people not to urinate in the buckets. If there wasn't enough sawdust in there it created quite a smell. We used bandanas with 3 drops of lavendar oil. The majority of us were women. This was on private rural land in NM. I was surprised and fascinated with the process. I have wanted a composting toilet but have not been able to afford one. I will certainly read through the info you have provided for us. Thanks.
     
  • Comment #14 (Posted by Will)

    Well, I did not read all the comments, because I was in a hurry, but I would like to add that if done correctly, the composting toilet will be a very good alternative to killing the world by chemicals or large use of water. Humans use the equivilant of the lake near my home a week to flush the poop in the world...Alot of water.

    Personally I have been using a composting home made system for several years, while other members of my family have been using them for 12-20 years. We live in Rural West Virginia....the US for those who don't know. We however take the humanure a step further by not adding to the current garden, even after the sompost has composted a long time, there is a small chance of contaminates from us, the carnivores. So we use it on our hay meadows and orchard, were the plants' fruit never touches the ground. We have done this a many year now and have one of the best organic gardens in the area, and yes we eat organic and wild animals, so not to kill ourselves or support the meat industry or dairy industry....so there....

    just giving this article affirmation...and I fully intend on reading that hand book again...thanks so much....a friend in pooh....

    will

    now where is my poop poking stick?
     
  • Comment #15 (Posted by Donna | The Healthy Eating Site)

    I'm really enjoying your site! What an informative and hilarious article (I've been giggling along too)! We live on 2 acres in rural New Zealand and I'm keen to set up a composting toilet. I've used them before, years ago when I was a woofer one farm I worked on had one, and the national parks here are starting to use them too. They are so much better than the traditional 'long drop' toilets. I've just downloaded the humanure handbook and I'm looking forward to reading it too. Thanks for providing a link to what sounds like a fantastic resource!
     
  • Comment #16 (Posted by Kristine )

    I have lived without a flush toilet in suburbia for the past 6 months. My loo broke down and being a student I did not have the money for a new one so I used an old fashioned toilet chair with a bucket system. I put a layer of compost in the bottom and every time I did the business I covered the lot with another layer of compost. No smell - no flies - not water wastage. I dug holes all over my back yard telling the neighbours I was planning major plantings of trees. And I will - plant trees in the holes in the future. I am now back to water wastage with a newly installed flusher and I actually miss the dig and bury routine - just a little. Thanks for the excellent site and information - have just downloaded the humanure freebie.
     
  • Comment #17 (Posted by Green Gal)

    Awesome post! Very informative :-)
     
  • Comment #18 (Posted by Donald)

    Proper recycling of human excreta is obviously a necessity in any quest for sustainability. Everyone is a walking manure factory. Sawdust is nice but how do you get it? Simple, inexpensive, and the least dependent on commercial support is good, at least for starters.

    And rewards? Humans, alas, need rewards to raise numbers above those who do things because it is the "Right thing to do."
     
  • Comment #19 (Posted by Jess)

    Living in Mexico, where the plumbing cannot handle the flushing of paper, I have drastically reduced my paper consumption simply by seeing how much was piling up in my rubbish bin and changing my habits. Your article on the use of urine in the garden will be altering further my sanitation habits. I encourage other folks to eschew flushing paper for a month to see for themselves. A good friend of mine who has been ecologically mindful for decades shocked me by going through nearly 20 rolls in just 3 weeks while she was house sitting for us.
     
Comment submission link (no longer in use - please use new form above)